This quintessential Mickey Rooney-Judy Garland musical has all the
kinetic energy and beaming goofiness that made their films together
(nine in all) so popular--and so easy to lampoon. The son of a vaudeville
performer Charles Winninger, Rooney decides to put on his own show
(in a barn!) to save his family's fortune, his town, his peers, and,
gosh darn it, even the American way of life. The star luster generated
by Garland matches the explosive energy of Rooney's performance. Director
Busby Berkeley's big production numbers are a sight to behold, from
a march through town for the title number to an embarrassingly dated
minstrel show routine. The movie was made the same year as The Wizard
Of Oz (1939) and featured the same villain: Margaret Hamilton. How
popular was Rooney at the time? The number one box-office attraction
was nominated for best actor at age 19 in that landmark year against
some of the most famous performances of all time: Laurence Olivier
in Wuthering Heights, Clark Gable in Gone With The Wind, James Stewart
in Mr. Smith Goes To Washington, and winner Robert Donat
in Goodbye, Mr. Chips.
The
film version of the Rodgers and Hart (1937) musical has been considerably
embellished in its transfer to the screen. Basic idea is there, and
two songs are retained. Otherwise, it's a greatly enhanced piece of
entertainment, with Mickey Rooney having a field day parading his
versatile talents. He sings, dances, gives out with a series of imitations
including Eddie Leonard, Clark Gable, Lionel Barrymore, and President
Roosevelt. With Judy Garland he sings "Good Morning," a new tune
by Nacio Herb Brown and producer Arthur Freed; he pounds the ivories;
he directs a kid's show to provide impersonations, and a dinner table
sequence, with a mix-up of decisions on the silverware, is an old routine
but his technique and timing make for grand fun. Direction by Busby
Berkeley is enthusiastic and at a fast clip throughout.
Variety
Rodgers and Hart's musical, minus most of their songs, and one that's left, "Where Or When," is trammeled to death. What remains is energetic but standard putting-on-a-show vehicle for Mickey and Judy. Dated fun. Originally ending was a production number spoofing Mr. and Mrs. Franklin D. Roosevelt, which was later removed for a 1948 reissue and never restored.
Pauline Kael - 5001 Nights At The Movies